Menu

Call This Wednesday to Get $50 OFF

Gas vs Electric Water Heaters
4.8 RATING

Gas vs Electric Water Heaters

Compare gas and electric water heaters by cost, efficiency, lifespan, and safety to determine which option best fits your home and budget.

765-228-2371
May 27, 2026
Gas vs Electric Water Heaters

Choosing the right water heater isn’t just about convenience; it’s also about energy efficiency, comfort, and longevity. Water heating accounts for nearly 18% to 25% of residential energy consumption. That’s a considerable cost that requires you to make the right decision. So if you’re weighing between a gas and electric water heater, you’ve come to the right place.

In this post, Rooter Man Plumbing breaks down the differences to help you make a choice that fits your household, budget, and lifestyle. If you’re considering water heater replacement in the near future, this post is for you.

Gas water heaters use natural gas or propane to heat water. A burner located at the bottom of the tank heats the water, and a flue vents combustion gases safely outside the home. On the other hand, electric water heaters rely on heating elements inside the tank to warm the water.

Cost To Install

Electric water heaters are usually cheaper to install because they don’t need gas connections or venting. You can expect to pay between $1,500 and $3,000 for electrical water heater installation. On the other hand, a gas-powered water heater costs a little more to install due to gas line upgrades, complex venting requirements, and permit acquisition. The average cost of installing a gas water heater ranges from $2,000 to $5,000.

Running Costs

Upfront costs for water heater installation are one thing, but operational costs are entirely another. Gas water heaters are cheaper to run day-to-day, especially for larger households. Modern, high-efficiency gas-powered water heaters outperform standard electrical heaters in terms of operating costs. We understand that there are high-efficiency electric water heaters as well, but still their gas-powered counterparts outperform them when it comes to running costs. If your heating bills keep rising, it may be time to consider upgrading to a more energy-efficient water heater. Consult with a local plumbing repair service if you need professional guidance.

Our Customer Reviews

Called Rooterman Plumbing of Muncie for a leaking pipe behind drywall. They serviced us within a few hours and we had our repair done by 5 p.m. Can't beat that! Thank you Rooterman Plumbing!

Veretta Teague

Yorktown, IN

Rooterman of Muncie is the best if you are having plumbing issues. Hands down best in the business in my opinion. From the start Lindsey handled the claim and the appointment for us. She was professional and very pleasant to deal with. We had to…

Cindy Goyak

Albany, IN

He's one of the most professional plumbers I've ever met really knows what he's doing very knowledgeable.And you guys are my plumbers. Anytime I need plumbing done, you guys will be doing my work very thankful that I found you.

Richard Moreillon

Richmond, IN

Dustin did an excellent job replacing our faulty gas line. He is professional, personable and very nice to work with. He explained options and processes very clearly. Our install required some challenges to overcome due to decking, grading, and structures. He explained possible plans of…

Sherri Keaton

Selma, IN

Lifespan and Maintenance

Both conventional gas and electric water heaters last between 8 and 12 years, depending on usage, water quality, and maintenance. Electric models tend to require less maintenance because they have fewer components that can fail. Gas units, on the other hand, need periodic inspections of burners, vents, and gas connections to ensure safe operation. Tankless models last between 15 and 20 years depending on maintenance, water quality, and the quality of installation. This is because they do not store water as in the case with storage water heaters. Whether you choose a conventional unit or a tankless system, leave the installation job to a trusted plumbing repair service.

Safety Considerations

Electric water heaters eliminate the risk of gas leaks and carbon monoxide exposure, making them safer in some respects. Gas water heaters are safe when installed and maintained correctly, but they require proper ventilation and regular inspections to prevent hazards. Make sure you hire a qualified and licensed plumber in Muncie, IN when it’s time to repair or replace your water heater.

Schedule Your Water Heater Replacement Service with Rooter Man Plumbing

If your current water heater has been showing signs of age, it might be time to consider installing a new one. You don’t want to find yourself without hot water in the middle of winter—the earlier you take action, the more likely you are to avoid unexpected breakdowns, emergency repairs, and costly water damage. Choosing between a gas vs. electric water heater is easier with professional help, and the experts at Rooter Man Plumbing are ready to guide you every step of the way. We’ve proudly offered dependable water heater services for over 40 years. Reach out today to book an appointment!

Coupons

Rooter Man Plumbing Coupons & Specials

Offer Expires January 2024
$35OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires January 2024
$100OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires January 2024
$150OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Offer Expires January 2024
10%OFF

Plumbing Services

Get $50 Off your plumbing repair service needs today.

Redeem it Today Print Now

Limit One Per Customer. Not Valid With Any Other Offer.

Latest News & Updates

27 May 2026

5 DIY Solutions for Simple Plumbing Issues

Although plumbing problems might be a homeowner's worst nightmare, not all of them call for a plumber's intervention. Numerous minimal…

Read More
27 May 2026

Types of Sewer Linings for Cracked Pipes

If you’ve ever dealt with a cracked or failing sewer line, you’ll understand why homeowners dread the thought of sewer…

Read More
27 May 2026

Tips For Clearing A Blocked Drain

Blocked drains are one of the most common plumbing issues homeowners encounter. As a homeowner, it is important to know…

Read More
27 May 2026

Crucial Things to Do During a Plumbing Emergency

You’ve probably been there. Frozen pipes disrupt the water supply to your water-using appliances. The toilet is blocked and unusable.…

Read More